You are currently viewing A Christmas Heart

A Christmas Heart

My friend Frank was a lovable piece of work. He was a teddy bear who liked to masquerade as a grizzly. When someone asked him: “How are you?” his response was: “None of your business, you’re not my doctor.” Frank refused to answer with a perfunctory “I’m fine.” All too often, “I’m fine” can be a polite lie. We say it out of habit whether we mean it or not.

Opening ourselves to Christmas begins with moving away from polite lies – including the ones we tell ourselves. It requires the humble admission that we’re not fine. It requires acknowledging that we need to be redeemed.

Acknowledging Our Need for Redemption

When I am humble enough to acknowledge my need for redemption, I am forced to admit that there are ways in which I resemble Ebenezer Scrooge. I may not be as stingy as the self-centered miser Charles Dickens created in A Christmas Carol. I do, however, share some of his tendencies.

Like Scrooge, I sometimes operate with a head-down, all-about-work orientation that keeps me from seeing the deeper meaning that is unfolding around me. I can also hide in the safety of my comfort zone rather than reaching out to those in need. Perhaps most miserly of all, my stingy heart sometimes hoards my gifts and uses them in self-serving ways rather than sharing them to serve others.

Both Scrooge and the Scrooge-in-me have a desperate need for redemption. He needed three ghostly nightmares to scare him into acknowledging that need. At the very least, I sometimes need a wake-up call before I’m willing to acknowledge it.

In contrast to Scrooge and me, Luke’s Gospel describes two people who humbly acknowledge the need for redemption. Simeon and Anna have their hearts set on it. Simeon “was righteous and devout, looking forward to the consolation of Israel, and the Holy Spirit rested on him.” (Luke 2:25) The moment that he saw the child Jesus, he recognized him as the long-awaited Messiah and began praising God. The prophet Anna also recognized Jesus. She “began to praise God and to speak about the child to all who were looking for the redemption of Israel.” (Luke 2:38) Simeon and Anna invite me – and all of us – to leave the Scrooge-in-us behind in order to acknowledge our need to be redeemed.

Opening Our Hearts to Redemption

In recognizing Jesus and praising God’s faithfulness, Simeon and Anna opened their hearts to redemption. Matthew’s Gospel provides a sharp contrast between those who are open to redemption and those that want no part of it. The wise men welcome Jesus – following his star, traveling a great distance to visit the infant, and presenting him with symbolic gifts. Herod, however, sees the child as a threat and responds with fear. He is furious when he realizes wise men have tricked him, and he orders the massacre of innocent children. Even as an infant, Jesus is welcomed by those who are open to the redemption. He is also feared by those who view him as a threat to their power and position. That dynamic occurs throughout Jesus’ life – ultimately resulting in his execution.

Seeing this contrast poses a question for us: are our hearts open to redemption, or are we threatened by it? Our answer may be a complicated mix of the two. To the extent we acknowledge our need for redemption, our hearts may welcome it. But, to the extent that we are threatened by the challenges redemption poses to life as we know it, we may find ourselves resisting it.

Growing the Room in Our Hearts

Luke’s Gospel suggests an image that invites us to open our hearts to the Christmas gift of redemption.

And she (Mary) gave birth to her firstborn son and wrapped him in bands of cloth, and laid him in a manger, because there was no place for them in the inn. (Luke 2:7)

Christmas invites us to create a place for Jesus in the inn of our hearts. It urges us to make room for God-with-us, Emmanuel.

Many words describe the heart. Some describe positive qualities: openhearted, warmhearted, bighearted, tenderhearted, wholehearted, and more. These heart qualities open us to redemption, welcome Christ, make room for those we love, and compel us to reach out to serve others.

Other words describe negative qualities of the heart: halfhearted, hardhearted, coldhearted, blackhearted, and more. These qualities cut us off from redemption, separate us from Christ, isolate us from those closest to us, and shun those in need.

Christmas poses a heart choice. It calls us to grow the room in our hearts for God-with-us, for those we love, and for all those in need. It urges us to continually stretch our hearts – extending them in welcome, expanding our circle of concern, and deepening our love until our heart has room for all those in need.

Three ghostly nightmares scare Ebenezer Scrooge into discovering his Christmas heart. They pry open his stingy heart so that he begins to see in new ways and make room for others. Each Christmas calls me – calls all of us – to leave behind the Scrooge-in-us. Each Christmas is an invitation to be more openhearted, tenderhearted, and wholehearted. Each Christmas urges us to grow the room in our hearts so that we are able to more fully embrace the mystery of God-with-us, more deeply love others, and more willingly extend ourselves to all those in need – particularly the poor and those most vulnerable.

May this year’s celebration of Christmas help you grow the room in your heart during this holy season and throughout 2025.

Merry Christmas!

Questions to Ponder

Here are some questions to help you reflect on your Christmas heart.

  • Are there ways in which you identify with Ebenezer Scrooge? If so, in what ways?
  • What is your response to needing to be redeemed?
    • In what ways are you open to it?
    • In what ways do you resist it?
  • What are some of the ways that you could open your heart more fully to redemption?
  • What are the heart words with which you identify most strongly?
    • Openhearted, warmhearted, tenderhearted, wholehearted, or others?
    • Halfhearted, hardhearted, coldhearted, blackhearted, or others?
  • During this Christmas season, how might you grow the room in your heart for Emmanuel, God-with us?
  • How might you continue to grow the room in your heart throughout 2025?