You are currently viewing Learning to Forgive Ourselves

Learning to Forgive Ourselves

Jesus didn’t tell us what happened after the celebration ended.

The prodigal son comes to his senses and returns to his father. He is embraced, forgiven, and celebrated. (Luke 15:11-32) But what happened after the party? Think about it. The now forgiven prodigal has to face “whatever’s next.” He is overwhelmed by the gift of his father’s love yet worried about his brother’s anger and rejection. He also has to face an inner challenge – learning to forgive himself.

I identify with the prodigal’s challenge; I struggle to forgive myself. Frankly, I tend to act more like the prodigal’s older brother than his forgiving father. I expect myself to be the dutiful son. I demand perfection, am hard to satisfy, and tend to punish myself for every misstep. At a deep emotional level, the older brother’s perfectionism and judgment have a grip on me – constantly reminding me that I don’t measure up. When I respond like the older brother, I am self-critical, angry at myself, and self-punishing.

The prodigal’s challenge – and mine – is to cultivate a heart like that of the forgiving father. Jesus describes the father’s behavior to demonstrate what God is like. The father embraces the prodigal, showers him with forgiveness and love, restores him to sonship, and celebrates his return. The older brother – both in the parable and in me – rejects his brother and wants to vent his anger by punishing him for his errant ways.

Forgiveness is an unearned gift of God’s mercy and love. The prodigal didn’t earn or deserve it; none of us do. The gift comes from God and from the people in our lives who love us no matter what. Ultimately, forgiveness also needs to be a gift we give ourselves. Those of us with older brother tendencies face a tough question: how do we learn to forgive ourselves? How do we cultivate a heart like that of the forgiving father? How do we extend mercy, forgiveness, and love to all that is broken, sinful, and unredeemed within us?

The parable provides us with some wisdom about learning to forgive ourselves and cultivating a heart like that of the forgiving father.

Acknowledging our sinfulness: Forgiveness requires acknowledging our faults and sinfulness. A turning point in the parable of the prodigal son occurs when “he comes to his senses.” (Luke 15:17) He admits that he has sinned and decides to return to his father. I find acknowledging my sinfulness hard to do. Throughout my life, I have invested enormous effort in denying my faults and shortcomings. I have gone to extreme lengths to hide my sins – all the while trying to project an idealized view of myself. I’ve tried to convince those around me that I have it all together. Yet, all the while, a deep part of me knew better. I was faking it.

Faking it blocks mercy and forgiveness. It walls us up in a shallow, incomplete, and even dishonest view of ourselves. Acknowledging our sinfulness begins with courageous honesty – with ourselves and with others. It requires admitting the full scope of who we are: gifted yet flawed, generous yet sinful, noble yet self-interested. Like the prodigal, coming to our senses requires acknowledging our faults and sinfulness.

Embracing ourselves with forgiveness: We face two challenges in embracing ourselves with forgiveness. The first is being able to hug the broken and sinful parts of ourselves. The second is being open to receiving and accepting that embrace in the dark, emotional places where we feel unredeemed.

Extending the embrace of forgiveness to the alienated parts of ourselves requires a profound shift. All too often, our self-acceptance is partial and conditional. We own the parts of ourselves we view as good while denying or rejecting the parts of ourselves we see as flawed, wounded, and sinful. Embracing ourselves with forgiveness requires seeing, accepting, and loving all that is unredeemed within us – the ugly as well as the beautiful. Self-forgiveness needs to extend beyond what is deserving to what is broken. Self-compassion needs to reach beyond what is worthy to what is flawed. Self-love needs to reach beyond the gifts to the wounds. Like the forgiving father, we need to welcome, accept, embrace, and forgive the prodigal within.

Extending the embrace of forgiveness is only part of the challenge. We also have to receive and accept that embrace in the deepest parts of us. We need to allow the forgiving embrace to reach all that is broken and hurting within us – transforming our hurt, our anger, and all the ways we are wounded and alienated. Accepting the embrace of forgiveness needs to penetrate the deepest emotions at the core of our being. It needs to permeate our heart of hearts; we need to feel it in our bones. 

Living as one who has been forgiven: Forgiveness isn’t magic, and it doesn’t happen in a moment. Forgiveness – including self-forgiveness – is a process that unfolds over time. The prodigal returned home, but he wasn’t home free. He still had to learn to forgive himself and to live in new ways. For us, the journey of self-forgiveness includes making fundamental changes – adopting new habits that foster self-forgiveness and prayerfully opening ourselves to the redemptive power of God.

Adopting new habits requires owning up to the habits that drag us down. One of mine is relating to myself with demeaning self-talk. I’m hard on myself – often putting myself down with harsh language. I tend to amplify my faults and downplay my strengths. This self-wounding perpetuates an unintended cycle of inner violence. I’m slowly learning to use positive self-talk to break that cycle, including using language that clearly expresses that I forgive myself. The old habits, however, have lived in me for decades; changing them isn’t easy. Fortunately, the spiritual journey is more than a self-improvement project; it is a call to place our trust in God.

Self-forgiveness urges us to prayerfully open ourselves to the redemptive power of God. The struggle to change long-standing habits reveals that we are unable to do so on our own. Determination and willpower simply aren’t enough. The deep emotional healing we need is a call to prayer. It urges us to return to God, ask for forgiveness, and trust God’s mercy and love. In prayer, we allow ourselves to become the prodigal – returning to the father in desperate need of forgiveness. In prayer, we surrender to the mercy of God – allowing ourselves to be wrapped in God’s forgiving embrace.

Learning to forgive ourselves is an ongoing journey that combines our own efforts with surrendering to the healing power of God. Even though we are forgiven, learning to live as one who has been forgiven continues as our spiritual journey unfolds.

What happened after the celebration? The prodigal’s spiritual journey continued, and ours does too. That journey calls us to leave behind the judgmental perfectionism of the older brother and cultivate the heart of the forgiving father. It invites us to learn to forgive ourselves by acknowledging our sinfulness, embracing ourselves with forgiveness, and learning to live as one who has been forgiven. The journey of self-forgiveness combines the patient work of learning new habits with prayerfully surrendering to God’s redemptive power. As the journey unfolds, we continue to cultivate the heart of the forgiving father – extending God’s mercy, forgiveness, and love to ourselves and to all those who need it.

Invitation to Prayer

This meditation invites you to open yourself to God’s mercy, forgiveness, and love.

Find a quiet place where you can be alone and uninterrupted for 15 to 20 minutes.

Begin by reflecting on your life – starting with your recent experience and going back over your past.

  • Try to identify ways you need to forgive yourself.
  • Simply call them to mind without dwelling on them.
  • Avoid guilt trips, self-criticism, and dragging yourself down.
  • Simply recall your need for self-forgiveness as gently as possible.

As you become aware of your need to forgive yourself, open yourself to God in prayer.

  • Perhaps it will be in a reverent silence . . . 
  • Maybe a few simple words will surface . . .
  • Perhaps you’ll respond with a physical gesture – such as opening your hands . . . 

Knowing you are in God’s presence, ask for whatever you need to forgive yourself: courage, gentleness, compassion, whatever . . . 

Open yourself to receive whatever gift God gives you – receiving and accepting it gratefully. 

  • Maybe you will receive it as a quiet knowing between friends . . . 
  • Perhaps a word or phrase will come to mind . . . 
  • Perhaps you will receive it as a physical sensation – such as a reassuring hand on your shoulder or a gentle embrace . . .
  • There is no need to force it, just let it be . . .
  • Perhaps you will need to be patient and keep waiting . . .
  • Trust that God is working deep within you whether you can sense the divine presence or not . . .

When you are ready, conclude the meditation in a simple, prayerful way.