It was a spur of the moment decision. A friend told us about a wonderful play he had attended in Chicago. Since it’s only a two-hour drive, we decided to make it an overnight trip: dinner, a hotel, Sunday worship at our favorite Chicago parish, brunch, and enjoying the Sunday afternoon performance. I made the arrangements online, and then it hit me: I had purchased tickets for the wrong performance!
It wasn’t a disaster! The tickets were for Saturday night rather than Sunday afternoon. In spite of that, I started beating myself up over the mistake. My self-talk went something like this: I can’t believe I did that! What was I thinking? How could I be so stupid? As my self-judgment began to digress into self-punishment, I had to get a grip on myself.
My response to purchasing the wrong tickets revealed how often I still operate in perfection mode. I talk about being merciful and forgiving, but I have a hard time forgiving myself. The ticket incident forced me to admit that mistakes are the part of being human that I hate. When I was a student, I always wanted the right answer. As a consultant, I wanted my advice to be sound. As a disciple, I want to do the right thing. When mistakes reveal how human I am, humility is a bitter pill to swallow.
Perfectionism has significant downsides. It sets an unattainable goal, and then it tempts us with arrogance as we try to achieve it. Thinking we can achieve perfection with strong willpower and relentless self-improvement is a slippery slope. When our efforts inevitably fall short, we are likely to judge ourselves harshly – even triggering an inner violence in which we beat ourselves up. Then, it’s tempting to try harder – doubling down on self-improvement efforts. Doing so perpetuates the cycle of perfectionism – intensifying self-judgment and self-punishment.
Forgiveness is a gift with the power to break the cycle of perfectionism. It is grounded in a deep understanding of the human condition. Forgiveness recognizes that to be human is to be both profoundly gifted and significantly limited. Because we are limited, mistakes and faults – even sinfulness – are virtually inevitable. The question is how we respond. Being human doesn’t give us a pass; we are responsible for the consequences of our actions. The gift of forgiveness, however, responds with mercy rather than condemnation. Accepting it has the potential to free us from the perfection trap.
Forgiveness is a gift we are called to give others. Peter raises an important question for disciples: “How often should I forgive? As many as seven times?” (Matt.18:21) Jesus’ answer frames our daunting challenge. “Not seven times, but, I tell you, seventy-seven times.” (Matt. 18:22) In effect, Jesus tells Peter – and us – there is no limit to the number of times we need to forgive others. The words of the Lord’s Prayer – “Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us” – help drive this home. Receiving the gift of God’s forgiveness calls us to gift others with forgiveness.
Forgiveness is a gift we need to give ourselves. For those of us caught in perfection mode, forgiving ourselves can be a challenge. The desire to be perfect triggers the egocentric desire to go it alone rather than relying on God. Acknowledging our mistakes, faults, and sinfulness is a bath in reality. Giving ourselves the gift of forgiveness is a call to transformation. Our self-judgment needs to dissolve into self-acceptance – embracing our limits and flaws as well as our gifts. Our self-condemnation needs to melt into self-compassion – gifting ourselves with the gentleness we extend to others. Learning to forgive ourselves is a spiritual discipline that gradually transforms self-judgment, self-hate, and self-violence into self-love.
Purchasing the wrong tickets became a redemptive irony on my spiritual journey. If I had purchased the right tickets, I might not have confronted the need to forgive myself. Perhaps my “wrong ticket moment” will encourage you to consider a mistake that revealed your need to gift yourself with forgiveness. Maybe you have a “wrong ticket moment” that can help you gift yourself with forgiveness. Or perhaps a “wrong ticket moment” is waiting in your future. In either case, I hope you learn to accept the unearned gift of forgiveness – from God and from others. May you also learn to gift yourself with mercy, forgiveness, and love!
Questions to Ponder
Here are some questions to help you ponder the gift of forgiveness.
- Have you ever experienced a “wrong ticket moment?”
- If so, what happened?
- How did you respond?
- Are there ways in which you operate in “perfection mode?”
- What situations evoke that response?
- What downsides do you see in the way you respond?
- What is your response to the gift of forgiveness?
- In what ways are you open to it?
- Are there ways in which you resist it?
- In what ways do you need to:
- Receive the gift of forgiveness?
- Extend that gift to others?
- Gift yourself with forgiveness?
- When you consider your own mistakes and “wrong ticket moments”:
- What have you learned?
- How would you like to respond in the future?